- CONFERENCES
- Past Events
- March 1, 2012
- June 29, 2011
- Feb. 25, 2010
- June 24, 2009
- Feb. 13, 2009
- May 29, 2008
- Feb. 2, 2008
- July 5, 2007
- Jan. 13, 2007
- Jan. 26, 2006
- Sept. 30, 2005
- June 23, 2005
- April 16, 2005
- Oct. 1, 2004
- April 29, 2004
- Jan. 18, 2003
- Nov. 23, 2002
- Jan. 18, 2002
- CD's/DVD's
|
Event: |
IARPP 10th Anniversary Conference 2012 |
Location: |
New York City, New York |
Venue: |
The Roosevelt Hotel |
Co-Chairs: |
Margaret J. Black, LCSW and Hazel Ipp, PhD |
2012 Conference Brochure
|
|
|
|
8:00 AM |
Registration & Coffee |
|
8:50 AM |
President's Welcome: Spyros Orfanos, PhD:
The Internationalization of Imagination |
|
|
|
A Conversation with Stephen Mitchell |
|
9:00 AM |
Discussants: Hazel Ipp, PhD, CANADA and Jody Messler-Davies, PhD, USA
Interlocutor: Lew Aron, PhD, USA
|
|
|
Abstract:
This Plenary will showcase a film of Stephen Mitchell speaking about his vision of the Future of
Psychoanalysis. Filmed in 1989 at the Boston Division 39 Meeting, This talk concentrates on Mitchell’s
departures form traditional psychoanalytic concepts and sets the stage for many of the constructs that
have become germane to our current thinking and the Relational Endeavor. These ideas will be further
considered by two discussants who will consider the specific ideas Mitchell addresses in the film and will
elaborate upon them with clinical material.
At the conclusion of this panel participants will be able to:
- Establish a greater familiarity with specific departures from Classical theory as conceptualized by
Mitchell
- Have a clearer understanding of the basic tenets of Relational thinking as these were envisioned by
Mitchell
- Establish a clear link between Relational theory and clinical practice and better understand the interface
between the two.
|
|
11:00 AM |
Adjournment of Plenary II & Coffee Break |
|
|
|
|
(11 Concurrent Sessions)
|
|
|
|
11:30 AM - 1:00 PM |
|
|
#1: Time Travel in the Clinical Process |
|
Presenters: Deborah Agrest, LCSW, USA and Christina Emanuel, MA, USA
Discussant: William Coburn, PhD, PsyD, USA
Moderator: Marsha Hewitt, PhD, CANADA |
|
Abstract:
Serving Time, Deborah Agrest
The author explores the ways in which a patient’s experience of time plays out in a relational
treatment, impacts the analyst, and ricochets back to the patient. Both inhabit multiple self-states as
they find themselves in a parallel flow of time. The use of the deep transferencecountertransference
matrices and enactment in mending a sense of time are discussed. How are we
to extrude experience into language or, indeed, the printed word? This contribution was shaped to
deliberately veer off the course of the prevailing structure of psychoanalytic literature. The reader
is invited to immerse her/himself in an experience, as we might allow baroque music to wash over
us in a darkened concert hall or in the privacy of our own living room. Themes repeat, in spirals, in
scores of variations. I have written with those in mind who listen intensely to material that is at first
confusing, repetitious, to be sat with, and allowed to wash over them.
Educational Objectives:
At the conclusion of my presentation, the participant will be able to:
- Describe how to elicit and engage with patients’ multiplicity of self-states with different
temporal lines.
- Describe how the deep transference/countertransference matrices and therapeutic enactment
can retroactively re-work patients’ early organizing relational paradigms, in this case, a
patient’s sense of herself in time.
Rarefied, Luminous Spaghetti: The “Swoosh” as You Enter the Future and the Future Enters You, Christina
Emanuel
Broke, broken, stuck, and undead, Parker came to me five years ago, an overmedicated zombie who
persistently wanted to die. A precocious and clever child, Parker was deflated, degraded, and
disappointed too many times by a family in which emotions and alcohol were shaken, not stirred.
He entered treatment struggling with the suicide of a dear friend and mentor, a series of unfulfilling
relationships that ended in debilitating depression, and, significantly, the trauma of having been
seduced by his previous therapist. In this paper I describe how my patient Parker becomes “stuck in
time,” his temporal response to the difficulties he has endured, and how, through our work, “time
comes in.” Drawing inspiration from, among others, Kurt Vonnegut’s Slaughterhouse-Five,
Adrienne Harris’ article “You Must Remember this,” and Freud’s concept of nachtraglichkeit, I
suggest new ways of thinking about time in an analysis, including adding the concept of
“beforeness” to accompany “afterwardsness.”
Educational Objectives:
- Describe the concepts of “temporal parts,” “afterwardsness,” and “beforeness” and explain how
they can be used in psychoanalysis.
- Describe the concept of “temporal bandwidth” in psychoanalysis, explaining the difference
between narrow and broad bandwidth when considering a patient’s experience in time.
|
|
|
#2: Death is Nothing At All: On Imagining Non-Existence –
A Relational Psychoanalytic Engagement of the Fear of Death |
|
Presenter: Martin Stephen Frommer, PhD, USA
Discussants: Susan Mailer, MA, CHILE and Sam Gerson, PhD, USA
Moderator: Stephanie Bot, PsyD, CANADA |
Abstract:
If what binds us together as human beings is the shared knowledge that we must die, what
simultaneously sets us apart, dividing us in opposing, if not warring camps, are the strategies or
belief systems we use to cope with this reality of existence. For many, religion provides the needed
palliative through its assurances that in one way or another death is not the end. For non-believers,
there is no such solace. The logic that if one no longer exists, one ceases to have a consciousness of
one’s state of being (or lack there of) does not readily find a home within the human psyche. Freud
addressed this difficulty by declaring that the mind simply cannot conceive of its own nonexistence,
setting the stage for a long standing relationship between psychoanalysis and death that
has been ultimately abandoning of the secular mind’s need to be joined psychoanalytically in
grappling directly with its own mortality. This essay emanates from an interest in psychoanalytic
process, specifically in relation to the existential dimension of experience, as it is lived between
analyst and patient. I explore what happens when the fact of death finds its way into analytic
discourse and becomes an object of scrutiny, as it does, in the treatments I describe. How can
minds engage and help one another in considering non-existence? How might relational
psychoanalytic thinking inform a response to this question? In presenting clinical material
concerning a patient who was terrified of death, I attempt to consider the interplay between the
analyst’s omnipotent self and his more vulnerable mortal self, as both aspects of his subjectivity
engaged with the patient’s fear of death. This paper considers the nature of the relatedness between
analyst and patient that fosters and facilitates the development of the patient’s “existential self.”
Educational Objectives:
- At the conclusion of my presentation, the participant will be able to explain how the fear of
death has been understood in psychoanalytic theory.
- At the conclusion of my presentation, the participant will be able to describe a form of
therapeutic engagement with the patient that can help the patient to deal more adaptively
with the fear of death.
|
|
|
#3: Transformations in Psychoanalysis:
The Role of Shame and Forgiveness |
|
Presenters: Margy Sperry, PsyD, USA and Sharon Ziv Beiman, PhD, ISRAEL
Discussant: Ruth Gruenthal, MSS, MSW, USA
Moderator: Maria Tammone, PhD, ITALY |
Abstract:
Clinical Attitudes and the Transformation of Shame, Margy Sperry
Contemporary psychoanalytic theorists differ in how they understand shame and these differences
have important clinical ramifications. Most contemporary thinkers believe that shame is initially
generated in interaction with caregivers. They diverge, however, in how they believe that shame is
elicited and maintained throughout life. Whereas some argue that sensitivity to shame is
intrapsychically maintained and evoked, others believe that shame is shaped and elicited in an
ongoing way by one’s relational milieu. This paper explores three attitudes that derive from process
(contextualist) theories, including intersubjective systems theory and psychoanalytic complexity
theory, and illustrates the role that these attitudes play in clinical work with shame-prone
individuals. It is concluded that the attitudes associated with contextualist theories help to derail the
shame-blame cycle, and support the patient’s capacity to face her throwness and to embrace
authentic existence.
At the conclusion of this presentation, participants will be able to define three attitudes that are
associated with contextualist theories and the role that these attitudes play in the mediation and
transformation of shame; and recognize the difference between attitudes which emanate from an
intrapsychic model of shame and those that emanate from a contextualist (process) model of shame.
Forgiveness Revisited: A Relational Platform for Integrating Forgiveness into Psychoanalytic
Theory, Sharon Ziv Beiman
This paper will present a case, on the basis of which I would like to propose forgiveness as a vital
therapeutic process, especially in therapeutic contexts in which the patient has been profoundly hurt
by significant others. In these cases injured self-states crystallize, dominated by a prevailing sense
of worthlessness and helplessness, alongside the perseveration of interpersonal dyads in which the
patient experiences herself as a victim. I will attempt to show that forgiveness adds an additional
and vital dimension to the therapeutic process, which is bound to and affected by concepts such as
reparation, empathy, containment, mutual recognition, working through, and creation of meaning,
though it does not overlap with them. After screening the historical and conceptual barriers that
have hindered the incorporation of the concept of forgiveness into psychoanalytical discourse, as
well as outlining contemporary efforts to integrate it into therapeutic theory, I will suggest that
forgiveness calls forth and requires a creative stance. This stance combines a philosophical-ethical
position that views forgiveness as a mutually releasing process, and stresses its contribution to the
reinvigoration of mentalization processes that were blocked as a result of trauma. A relational
conceptualization of forgiveness as a dialectical process that enables and promotes an infinite
oscillation between blaming and forgiving self-states, between the positions of victim and
perpetrator, between the intra- and the interpersonal, between the emotional and the sexual –
heading towards mental movement and liberation from the constant repetition of pain and injury –
will be delineated.
Educational objectives:
At the conclusion of my presentation the participant will be able to:
- Recognize the historical and conceptual barriers that have hindered the incorporation of the
concept of forgiveness into psychoanalytical discourse, and outline contemporary efforts to
integrate it into therapeutic theory.
- Describe the relational theory’s contribution in conceptualizing forgiveness as a dialectical
process and in constructing it as a meaningful and integrative dimension of the therapeutic
endeavor.
|
|
#4: Relating: Danger and Possibility |
|
Presenters: Danielle Knafo, PhD, USA and Valeria Pulcini, MD, PhD, ITALY
Discussant: Daniel Shaw, LSCW, USA
Moderator: John Skrovan, PhD, USA |
Abstract:
A Journey from Extreme Solitude to Relatedness: A Case of Hikikikomori, the Japanese Shut-in,
Danielle Knafo
This paper describes the fascinating treatment of a singular young Japanese man, Hisoka, who
epitomized the phenomenon of Hikikikomori. The hikikikomori are young people who live
extremely solitary lives, never leaving their homes and hardly coming out of their rooms. At the
onset of therapy, Hisoka only emerged for his therapy sessions and even then he hardly
participated in a usual manner. The therapeutic work involved the creation of a safe holding
space within which Hisoka learned to face the derailments of his early attachments and to engage
in a mutual relationship. He gradually took steps to interact with the analyst and the outside
world. The experience transformed both him and the analyst.
Educational Objectives:
At the conclusion of my presentation, the audience will be familiar with the Japanese culturalbound
syndrome called Hikikikkomori, an extreme schizoid condition; and more conversant with
therapeutic ways to work with severe isolation and solitude.
A “Miri”, Many “Miris”, and Their Dance Together on a Stage, Valeria Pulcini
The last decades have seen the rise of different approaches in the contemporary psychoanalytic
field, due, among others, to the creative contribution of Stephen Mitchell. The case report hereby
presented, concerns a severely traumatized, and dissociated patient with whom the traditional
approach turned out to be hardly applicable. Beginning with a metaphor by Mitchell, applying his
multiple Self theory, and also using several works by other Authors, I’ve put to test various
methods, and some non-interpretative tools during the treatment, thanks to which my patient and I
were able to achieve considerable change. This exploration from multiple perspectives, namely the
implicit, the explicit, the “play space”, the “improvisational moments”, the “moments of meeting”,
all together on a “metaphorical stage”, allowed us to understand and to create an intense
relationship between us, and enabled her dissociated Selves to come to light, and “dance” together
with me, in a movement of cohesion.
Educational Objectives:
At the end of my presentation the participant will be able to:
- Appreciate Mitchell’s relevant perspective on “Multiple Self”;
- Discuss some non-interpretative tools helpful in accessing the otherwise inapproachable
inner dissociated world of my patient;
- Analyze and discuss the risks related to the use of these non-conventional techniques,
referring to this case of dissociation in which the collusion with the split parts might’ve been
possible;
- Consider these instruments as a possible way to approach the procedural memory.
|
|
#5: Philosophical Underpinnings of Intersubjectivity |
|
Presenters: Gabriel Vallejo Zeron, MD, MEXICO and Elizabeth Corpt, MSW, USA
Discussant: Christine Kieffer, PhD, USA
Moderator: Andrea Bleichmar, PsyD, USA |
Abstract:
Review of Phenomenology Psychoanalytic Intersubjectivity, Gabriel Vallejo Zeron
This paper addresses the influence of phenomenology on psychoanalysis starting with the critique
that the former has made of positivism in the latter intent to eliminate the subjectivity of the
observer. The contribution of phenomenology concerning the experience of the other not mediated
by conscious representations is enhanced. This suggests the existence of a corporeal subject and a
primary intersubjectivity in which phenomenological empathy is based. The incarnated subject is
related to affects and their regulation in an intersubjective yield. In the search for the conscious and
unconscious meanings of the psychoanalytic experience this has determined that psychoanalysis has
moved towards a phenomenological contextualism. A clinical vignette is presented to illustrate the
Concepts related to the phenomenological turn to end with a discussion in which jive concepts that
guide the practice of a phenomenological oriented psychoanalysis are put forward.
Educational Objectives:
- Discern the difference between RELATIONAL Intersubjectivity vision, compared to the
positivist view in psychoanalysis, phenomenology, hermeneutics, poetic, etc.
- Arguing about the deep value and strength of the relational view and its philosophical
underpinning.
- Show a case where inter-relational approach show and difference from the classical approach in
psychoanalysis.
The Ethical Turn in Psychoanalysis: Contemporary Pragmatism and the Engagement With
Otherness, Elizabeth Corpt
In this paper, I intend to explore what I am calling the ethical turn in psychoanalysis; a turn that
again calls up Pragmatism’s influence. In light of this, I believe a revisiting of some of the
contemporary tenants of Pragmatism is in order, not only as it pertains to the plurality within
psychoanalysis, but more importantly, as it pertains to the pragmatics of responding to intimate
pluralities – the actual engagement of otherness - in the consulting room.
Educational Objectives:
At the conclusion of the presentation, participants will be able to:
- Comprehend the meaning of the ethical turn in psychoanalysis and it’s relevance to
psychoanalysis.
- Understand and apply the pragmatics of engaging otherness in the consulting room.
|
|
#6: When (and Why) Analyst and Patient Change Together |
|
Presenters: Phyllis DiAmbrosio, PhD, USA and Alan Sirote, LCSW, USA
Discussant: Aner Govrin, PhD, ISRAEL
Moderator: Janet Kelly, MSW, USA |
Abstract:
Patient and Analyst in Crises: A Mutual Transformation Reflected in a Clinical Narrative and
St. Exupery's “The Little Prince,” Phyllis DiAmbrosio
In this paper I will describe and illustrate how personal crises of patient and analyst, in contrast to the
more commonly recognized detrimental effect, can actually facilitate a mutually transformative process.
While I was in the throes my own personal crisis, a very challenging patient arrived for treatment. How
that analysis evolved over the course of 12 years to become a mutually transformative and creative
process for both the patient and myself is the focus of this paper. To augment delineation of this
process, I will use St. Exupery's The Little Prince as a literary depiction of what I believe to be the
essential healing elements involved, poignantly illustrated through presenting a film clip from the
cinematic version of the book.
At the conclusion of my presentation, participants will be able to discuss the circumstances in which
psychoanalysis can potentially be a mutually transformative experience for both the patient and the
analyst; and describe how an attitude of creativity, mutuality and openness can help to create a mutually
healing environment in an analysis.
The Patient Who Had Me Committed: A Mutually Influential Relationship between
Patient and Analyst in the Context of a Broadening Analytic Frame, Alan Sirote
Patients and analysts frequently become locked in enactments generated by their reciprocal
dissociations. Emerging from this quagmire often entails the capacity of the dyad to confront each other
and negotiate out of these impasses. When discussing the analyst’s role in facing her own dissociations
much of the analytic literature refers to minor omissions or blind spots that are effectively dealt with by
slight attitude adjustments toward the patient. I suggest that, in some instances, the therapist’s
willingness to grapple with her deeper and more profound detachments while struggling and negotiating
with her patient’s dissociations could lead to intense mutual influence and spirited enlivening
collaboration between the two, including invitations to participate in architecting the therapy itself. This
thoroughgoing relational process could be further advanced by broadening the analytic frame to include
external environmental factors. A detailed case vignette is presented.
Educational Objectives:
At the conclusion of my presentation the participant will be able to illustrate the advantage of embracing a
more comprehensive relational and environmental approach to therapeutic action. There are two educational
objectives in this: (1) The therapist’s willingness to grapple with her deeper and more profound detachments
while struggling and negotiating with her patient’s dissociations could lead to intense mutual influence and
spirited enlivening collaboration between the two, including and especially invitations to participate in
architecting the therapy itself. (2) This thoroughgoing relational process could be further advanced by
broadening the analytic frame to include external environmental factors. |
|
#7: Shared vulnerabilities in Development and Treatment |
|
Presenters: Ruth Livingston, PhD, USA and Etan Lwow-Maier, MD, ISRAEL
Discussant: E. Joyce Klein, LICSW, USA
Moderator: Antonia Piazza, PhD, ITALY |
Abstract:
Limping Along, Together: Finding a Balance in the Consulting Room, Ruth Livingston
This paper explores the issue of the disabled therapist. Specifically, the author considers how her
limp enters the analytic process, both with patients who also have gait problems and with those who
do not. Using the “limp” as a metaphor for feelings of unsteadiness and vulnerability, internally and
relationally, the author considers the ways in which her disability is incorporated by her patients to
understand their own feelings of being “off balance”, and how this and the concept of “moving
unsteadily” often refer to the process itself. One question is how cultural images of “lameness” are
translated within the intersubjective field by both participants, sometimes resulting in mutuality, at
other times leading to disconnection. Case vignettes illustrate the complex dynamics that ensue
when this analyst’s limp becomes a conscious focus or is dissociated in the consulting room.
Educational Objectives:
At the conclusion of my presentation, the participant will be able to:
- Discuss how the analyst’s limp may impact the psychoanalytic relationship, and how
stereotypical images of disability are dissociated or enacted in the clinical encounter.
- Describe how an analyst with a mobility disability might use the metaphor of imbalance and
“lameness” to explore intrapsychic dynamics and interpersonal relatedness with patients who
themselves have mobility challenges and with those who do not.
The “River Banks” Parental Function - Development in the Shadow of Unrecognized Permissions, Etan
Lwow-Maier
The lecture is an attempt to offer a novel understanding of the self-other co-construction of the
self’s healthy or pathological development. We are accustomed to see the relational impact between
two subjects as reflecting a web of hidden and overt intensive interactions between two worlds of
emotionally charged psychological motives and forces flowing between the two subjects; one
subject’s motives acting, reacting and interacting with the subjective world of the other subject and
vice versa in a reciprocal-circular way. The paper suggests that the other’s subjectivity has also a
different critical function, as a kind of “potential space” for the development of the self.
The view of the other’s subjectivity not only as a source of intersubjective motives for the self, but
also as a critical potential space for the development of the self, changes the arena of treatment. This
perspective has allowed for the development of an innovative therapeutic treatment - mediated by
the parents - for children, adolescents, or young adults who refuse treatment or suffer from resistant
psychological disturbances. A developmental and a clinical example will illustrate the concepts of
the paper.
Educational Objectives:
- At the conclusion of my lecture, the audience will understand a clinically useful, critical function
of the significant other in the co-construction of individual developmental psychopathology
- The lecture will generate interest in an important but usually overlooked parental intersubjective
function, essential for promoting a stable “direction” toward health and maturity for the developing
self; as well as in the applicable interventions towards that aim.
|
|
#8: Varieties of Coupling in Psychotherapy and Assessment |
|
Presenters: Helene Beinoglou, MA, GREECE and Marco Bernabei, PhD, ITALY
Discussant: Lawrence Josephs, PhD, ABPP
Moderator: Irit Paz, MA, ISRAEL |
Abstract:
Finding My Own Voice Working as a Couple Therapist, Helene Beinoglou
The paper I present links my work as an analytical psychotherapist with my personal history. I
attempt to describe briefly the notion of transgenerational transmission of trauma and repetition.
Repetition is a desperate attempt to find a pathway in life where the consequences of traumas have
been dissociated. It is a potentially destructive way of regaining a psychic foothold. Finally it is the
perpetuation of a scenario that prevents a sense of freedom, aliveness and creativity. Submission to
the past imprisoned me, leaving me powerless as a child. The internalization of the bad internal
objects used to fill the void of the absent other, creating a false self personality and containing the
sense of vacuum inside. This is a journey from a sense of isolation and emptiness to a feeling of
aliveness and creativity by [re]connecting to the traumatized parts of myself.
In the second part of my paper I describe two vignettes of Couples Therapy with deeply traumatized
couples (sexual and non-sexual abuses) with violent behaviors. These couples needed to discover a
way to [re]connect their violence to their past abuses. In both cases, secrets had destroyed their
capacity for association or symbolization and their traumatic history was perpetually repeated
within the couple relationship. I try to show that these repetitions reinforced a sense of total
estrangement and absolute aloneness in relation to their environment. I describe how the creation of
a protective shield in therapy was necessary before they dared acknowledged their violent, hateful,
fearful traumatized parts of self. The therapeutic work is concentrated on the countertransferential
feelings and non-verbal elements of the sessions, used to access unelaborated material.
Educational Objectives:
At the conclusion of my presentation, the participants will be able to:
- Relate feelings of estrangement and aloneness to the transgenerational repetition of past traumas.
- Explain the importance of the acknowledgement of the therapist’s personal history and the way
she relates to it.
- Describe how the elements of the personal history of the therapist can create transferential and
countertransferential bridges with couple.
- Describe how accessing our traumatized parts of self can foster our sense of creativity and
aliveness.
Taking Into Therapy Only the Parents or Also the Son/Daughter? A Criterion for Choosing During the
Assessment with the Parental Couple, Marco Bernabei
In the paper I suggest some criteria that can be used during the assessment of a therapeutic plan for
psychotherapeutic treatment during development when the decision needs to be made as to whether one
should continue to see only the parents or involve their son/daughter in the treatment as well. The
criterion for suggesting one setting or the other depends on the image which the parents offer to the
therapist of their child: when the image of “the mother’s son” does not appear to be too discrepant from
that of the “father’s son”, it is possible to suggest that one continue to see only the parents. On the
contrary, the need for the therapist to see also the son/daughter arises when the image of the child (or
boy/girl) presented by one of the parents is so different from that of the other that one gets the
impression one is dealing with two different children, that of the mother and that of the father. In this
regard, I explain that the reason for deciding to see also the child is that, coming directly into contact
with some of his/her traits, bypassing the filters introduced by the father or mother, will allow the
therapist to present them again to both parents in less of a dissociated way so that together they may
start a process to reconstruct more of a shared image of a child-son/daughter. Mitchell’s (Mitchell,
1993) statements regarding the repercussions of the differences between the mother’s child and the
father’s son within the universal conflict among the different self-organizations are associated with the
idea that underpins this paper, according to which when the mother’s child is altogether different from
that of the father the result is not a mere conflict among self-organizations but an actual dissociation
between such self-organizations (reference is made to non-communication among rigidly dissociated
self-organizations, as postulated by Bromberg) (Bromberg, 2006). I also posit that the onset of such
dissociated self-organizations depends on how the parents-child identification processes are played out.
In the paper, I suggest that when it comes to choosing a setting, the best way to proceed, if one begins to
notice that the conflict among the child’s self-organizations (arising from his/her identifications with the
discrepant views the parents have of his/her unripe self) runs the risk of resulting in, or indeed has
already resulted in dissociation, is to take into therapy both the parents and the child. I have become
convinced that, when instead the views of the child produced by the two parents are only slightly
different, it is not only possible but indeed advisable to try to work only with the parents. As the clinical
vignettes of therapeutic treatments involving only the parents show, in these cases the therapeutic work
will focus primarily on reducing the discrepancy between their views of the child. I describe how, in the
setting which involves only the parents, seeing them alternately, first individually and then as a couple,
allows the therapist to serve as a shuttle between the parents and their images of the child which are
conveyed from one to the other during their individual sessions and are then shared with both so that
they may be discussed together during the couple sessions. |
|
#9: Thinking About Creativity:
Emily Bronte, Heinz Kohut and Thomas Hardy |
|
Presenters: Barbara Feld, LCSW, USA; Barbara Schapiro, PhD, USA and
Charles Strozier, PhD, USA
Discussant: Sandra Hershberg, MD, USA |
Abstract:
Emily Bronte: A Private Self in the Context of an Insular Family: A Focus on the Effects of
Creativity, Barbara Feld
Thinking about the life of Emily Bronte, the author of one of the most famous novels in the English
language, Wuthering Heights, is helpful in understanding the creative transformation of the
experience of traumatic loss. In this presentation, I will illustrate the basis for Emily’s entrapment in
the sequence of traumatic losses through death of family members, and discuss several themes that
can be observed in her development. Other additional theses I have developed include her struggle
to find freedom and individuate in the midst of intense dependency, and her ability to transform
trauma into art through her creative fantasies. Her imagination, creativity, wanderings on the moors,
and her extensive writing were fertile ground for the expression of her will. Her poems and her
novel Wuthering Heights were integral to her moments of individuality.
Learning objectives:
- A listener will learn about the development of creativity in a family context and it’s use in
dealing with traumatic loss.
- A listener will come to understand the parallels between life and art in Emily Bronte’s
creations.
Creativity, Passion, and Romance: Reading Thomas Hardy Through the Lens of Stephen Mitchell,
Barbara Schapiro
Three themes in Stephen Mitchell’s work—creativity, passion, and romance—resonate closely with
those of the British Victorian writer Thomas Hardy. Both Mitchell and Hardy explore the perpetual
tension between our inner subjective world, with its fantasies, passions, and creative projections,
and an inexorable external reality. Reading Hardy’s fiction through the lens of Mitchell’s theorizing
can shed light on Hardy’s passionately romantic characters and illuminate a complex
psychodynamic tension at play in his novels. Equally it is hoped that this discussion will further
appreciation of Mitchell’s ideas as they find expression in fictional form.
Educational Objectives:
At the conclusion of my presentation, the participant will be able to explain Stephen Mitchell’s ideas
about the dialectical relationship between fantasy and actuality and to describe how that dialectic
operates in Thomas Hardy’s fiction; and explain how idealization and aggression inform Stephen
Mitchell’s ideas about romance, and they will be able to illustrate those ideas through examples from
Hardy’s fiction.
Heinz Kohut and Creativity: At the Frontier of Self Knowledge, Charles Strozier
Paper addresses the theme of creativity in the life and work of Heinz Kohut. In the first part the
story is how he himself embraced music, art, and literature in profound ways in his own life,
including his favorite artists and musicians, as well as the reading that most appealed to him. The
second part of the paper describes the creative transformation of Kohut’s ideas about
psychoanalysis in the 1960s and how the new theory, culminating in his greatest work, The
Analysis of the Self in 1971, went along with a remarkable change in the kind of literature and art
that had meaning for him.
Learning objectives:
- A listener will learn about the workings of creativity in psychoanalytic theory and how
personally challenging it can be to engage new ideas.
- A listener will come to understand some aspects of the intellectual journey of Heinz Kohut.
|
|
#10: On Butterflies and Dynamic Systems in the Consulting Room |
|
Presenters: Raimundo Guerra Cid, PhD, SPAIN & Yakov Shapiro, MD,
FRCPC, CANADA
Discussant: Karen Rosica, PhD, USA
Moderator/Interlocutor: Susan Bodnar, PhD, USA |
Abstract:
Why Can Even A Fluttering of a Butterfly's Wings Change Everything: A Chaos Perspective and
A Complexity of Therapeutic Relations, Luis Guerra Cid
Along the history of psychoanalysis there has been a tendency to think that the processes that take part
in therapy (diagnostics, etiology of psychopathology, transference, processes and phases of treatment)
have lineal tendencies of “The therapist interprets and the patient accepts what the analyst says and
experiences insight or, ultimately, resists” type. This has two consequences: an illusion of linearity
based on the fact that the therapist and the patient move always in the same segment forwards and
backwards; and a more static role in both with some default rules (patient’s free association that needs to
comprehend the objective reality that the therapist proposes and the therapist’s abstinence and neutrality
that is interpreted when the “objective truth” is known”). S. Mitchell (1993) commented that apart from
the importance of the insight we are to evolve towards the observation of other elements like the
relational expansion and the experiential part that it connotes. The hard sciences that have been working
for a long time with the Nonlinear dynamic systems theories (NLDS) bring forward the importance of
the complexity and relative chaos that exists in the complex systems. The contemporary psychoanalysis
can also work from this perspective provided that the existing difference between our object of studies
(a human being immersed in relations) and the elements studied by the hard sciences are taken into
consideration as various authors do, putting that into practice from the relational perspective (Selligman,
2005; Lyons-Ruth, 2010; D.B. Stern, 2010 Marks-Tanlow, 2011). In this way, the NLDS shows that
different actions, enactments and all the shared relational knowledge indicate implicit dynamics, nonlineal
and dynamic in the therapeutic processes. So as to explain all that issues we will start with a
simile that comes from certain approaches from the recent theories of hominization in anthropology.
Those apply to certain aspects of the complexity and of the NLDS in the human evolution. Hereupon we
will provide divergent explanations to the classic ones on the etiology and maintenance of
psychopathologies and of some characteristics of the relation as a technique itself for the progress of the
treatment.
Educational Objectives:
Describe and explain which are the consequences of taking the NLDS models and the theory of
complexity both in etiology and maintenance of psychopathology and in the therapeutic relation.
With this presentation it is intended that the participant learns throughout this theories the
mechanisms that cause the progress of a therapeutic relation or change the registers (for example,
over moment to moment interactions or because of the accumulation of emotional feedbacks
between the therapist and the patient).
Psychodynamic Formulation in the Age of Neuroscience: A Dynamical Systems Model, Yakov
Shapiro
Dynamical systems approach to neural network functioning offers the most comprehensive
foundation for psychotherapy available to us today. Recurrent patterns of thinking, feeling, and
relating can be analyzed by modeling cortical and subcortical network processes. Dynamical
Systems Therapy (DST) stands as a trans-theoretical model with the explanatory power to integrate
systems of synaptic networks with systems of meaning. It powerfully argues for shifting the
emphasis from maladaptive patterns as the problems in themselves – to seeing them as patients’
imperfect solutions to their inner and relational conflicts. Patients are seen as active agents who
create the subjective meaning of their experiences based on specific developmental templates.
Therapeutic relationship becomes our tool in re-shaping the topology of the patient’s neural network
landscape and re-establishing self-organizing process.
Educational Objectives:
At the conclusion of this presentation, the participants will be able to:
- Carry out a comprehensive psychiatric assessment without the artificial separation into
biological vs. psychological domains in order to construct a unique individualized treatment
plan for the patient integrating both psychotherapeutic and biological interventions.
- Use DST framework as a trans-theoretical teaching tool to help psychiatric trainees see
beyond the manualized assessment, and incorporate the patient’s unique subjectivity into
biopsychosocial case formulation.
|
|
#11: Relational Complexities: Challenges of Contemporary Work |
|
Presenters: Stanley Rabin, PhD, ISRAEL; Etziona Israeli, MA and Carla Leone, PhD, USA
Discussant: Mary-Joan Gerson, PhD, USA
Moderator: Maurizio Pinato, PhD, ITALY |
Abstract:
The Psychotherapist, The Patient and The Lover: Caught in the Web of Virtual Relationships,
Etziona Israeli and Stanley Rabin
The Internet has created a new kind of social space where people are "meeting and mating" in new
ways. The meeting between people on the web is unique in that there is no corporeal body, no touch, no
sensual impressions, this in contrast to real-life meeting, in which one detects something out of the
ordinary, reacts to body language, reacts to verbal and nonverbal communication. The thrust of our
presentation will be to consider the actual significance and meaning of the cyberspace encounter as told
by the patient and its interwoven expression in the psychotherapeutic relationship. Our paper will
attempt, through the presentation of a case, to trace the development of this new phenomenon of virtual
romantic love relationships on the internet.
Educational objectives:
- Through the virtual relationship of the patient, the therapist understands the patient's difficulties in forming
relationships.
- Through the emotions that the therapist feels in the therapeutic session he/she learns about the dynamic
processes that occur in the patient therapist relationship.
The Unseen Spouse: Pitfalls and Possibilities for the Individual Therapist, Carla Leone
Individual therapists frequently hear a great deal about their patients’ spouses or partners, and naturally
develop ideas and beliefs about that person and about the causes of any relationship difficulties.
However, problems arise when therapists lose touch with the fact that their impressions of an unseen
spouse are only constructions that have emerged from the transference-countertransference field, based
on only partial or limited information – not veridical truths. They can then begin to speak about the
patient’s partner or relationship issues in ways that can ultimately do both patient and spouse a
disservice and perhaps distract from the patient’s own issues and analytic goals. This paper discusses
several factors that seem to contribute to the development of this problematic dynamic, including
various qualities of the transference-countertransference field, and offers suggestions for avoiding or
reducing it. Clinical material is used to illustrate key points.
Educational Objectives:
By the end of this presentation, participants will be able to:
- Discuss the problems that can occur when individual therapists develop strong feelings or opinions
about an individual patient’s spouse or partner, despite having never met that person.
- List several factors that contribute to the development of this problematic dynamic or phenomenon
- List several ways to avoid or minimize the development of the problem
|
|
1:00 PM |
Adjournment of Paper Session 2 and Lunch (on your own) |
|
|
|
|
Two Realms of the Analyst's Will:
Unbidden Intentions and Committed Choices |
2:30 PM |
Presenters: Irwin Hoffman, PhD, USA and Donnel Stern, PhD, USA
Interlocutor: Malcolm O. Slavin, PhD, USA |
“[T]he self is created from meanings assigned to experience; one cannot begin to understand a
life, a person, without an appreciation of those experiences and what they provide in terms of
possibilities and constraints. But the meaning of those experiences is not given; it is composed,
created, designed. The self is not produced by motives and causes; there is also the creative will
of the individual.” (from Relational Concepts in Psychoanalysis,1988, p. 257)
Abstract:
This panel will explore the dialectical interplay in the analyst's experience of finding himself or
herself "feeling inclined" to act and proactively exercising will to influence the process.
Sometimes what seems to be in the foreground is the sense of "unbidden" experience that is the
impetus for new understanding and action (Stern's emphasis), sometimes what is in the
foreground is a sense of determination to affect the patient and the analytic relationship in a
particular way (Hoffman's emphasis). The wellspring for the analyst's experience can never be
fully known and yet certain moments become inspirational for creative exploration of new
possibilities.
- Attendees should be able to define relational freedom and apply the concept to clinical
situations in their own experience.
- Attendees with gain understanding of how analytic therapists' proactive, creative
efforts in a constructivist framework to inspire change in their patient’s lives can be integrated
with a critically reflective analytic attitude and with awareness of the never fully known or
controlled foundations for changing perspectives.
- Attendees will gain understanding of how analytic therapists' explicit expressions of
loving affirmation can do battle with the destructive effects of persecutory introjects and provide
fertile ground for the emergence in the patient of new possibilities and new hope.
|
|
4:30 PM |
Adjournment of Plenary III and Coffee Break
IARPP Membership Meeting
Adjournment for the day |
|
Back to the Top
|